Suggestion for unified button mapping for all iriver remotes.

[Mmmm]

I think you'll find it is now all just as you would want it to be!

[Davide-NYC]

Just to update since I linked to this thread from elsewhere.

H100 remotes works as Mmmm explained for maximized one-handedness.
H300 remotes work as they should *plus* pressing the -10 button turns off the RLCD updating during recording, thus removing the ticking problem.

I still think my 'unified remote button mapping' is a valid idea, but since I don't use the H100 remote and the H300 is perfect it's moot for me.

 

[fizze]

I hate to do crossposting, but this thread seems more appropriate.

Someone mentioned "one-handedness" WTF?
Its more like one-fongeredness. which seems plain weird to me.
I liked it the was it was, using the index finger to browse back/forward, and NAVI to select one tune. I could use the thumb to browse up/down in the folder hierarchy. which was great. I just want that back.

[Mmmm]

So your issue isnt with what the NAVI and stop buttons do at all, it is solely about the vol +/- buttons... Is that true?

If the Vol+- buttons were given the functionality you propose, then we would lose some other functionality (namely scrolling left/right) and seeing as it is already possible to navigate through folders (using stop and NAVI) repeating the function on a different set of keys at the expense of another function is a definite no-no... in my opinion of course

[Davide-NYC]

Fizze: Please make up a table, or post a picture. I don't understand what button mapping you are proposing exactly.

Here's the wiki page http://www.rockbox.org/twiki/bin/view/Main/KeymapIriverHSeries

[fizze]

Right, I will do when I have a few minutes to spare.
Thanks already for your understanding.