ReplayGain for WMA files not working (RB 3.9, Sansa E280v2)

[tuktoyaktuk]

First off, thanks to all the devs for such awesome firmware. It has vastly extended the useful life of my E280v2.

I have just recently updated from RockBox 3.7 to 3.9 and I noticed that ReplayGain is no longer working for my WMA files. It works fine for MP3 files and it was working properly for WMA files prior to the update. I used Winamp to add ReplayGain tags to all of my WMA files.

I am using the arboxWidgets theme, so it shows the ReplayGain values for the playing track on the WPS. In RB 3.9, it shows 0.00 as the ReplayGain value for any WMA file that is playing. If the track has no ReplayGain tags, "No RG Tag" would be displayed on the WPS.

When I select "Show Track Info" for each WMA track that is playing, no ReplayGain fields or values are shown.

I just downgraded to RB 3.8 and ReplayGain is working properly again for the same WMA files and when I select "Show Track Info" for a WMA track, the ReplayGain fields and values are shown. They are also properly displayed on the WPS.

It seems like there may be a ReplayGain bug in RB 3.9. I get the same result using the latest daily build. Should I submit a bug report? Thanks.

[Buschel]

Yes, please submit a bug report.

Edit: I have an idea what might caused this. Can you please check the build e200v2-build I have uploaded (http://www.sendspace.com/file/dwp61j)?

Edit 2: Could reproduce and fix it. Sorry for any inconvenience :/

[tuktoyaktuk]

That worked perfectly! ReplayGain is now working for WMA files. Thanks so much for the quick response.

I'm not sure if this is related in any way, but I just noticed that mp3 files are now showing as mp2 codec on the WPS. They play fine and ReplayGain works fine for all, so it's no big deal for me. I checked on my Fuze that is running yesterday's daily build and mp3 files display the mp3 codec on the WPS.

Thanks again!

[yapper]

I'm not sure if this is related in any way, but I just noticed that mp3 files are now showing as mp2 codec on the WPS.

Is this running the build Buschel provided or with an official build? r30259 onwards include the fix.

[tuktoyaktuk]

Yes, this happens running the build provided by Buschel. Thanks.

[Lear]

I'm not sure if this is related in any way, but I just noticed that mp3 files are now showing as mp2 codec on the WPS.

That's probably due to r30225, which changes the order of the values in the %fc tag. It now starts with MP2, MP3, MP1... (rather than MP1, MP2, MP3...)

[Llorean]

Would that require the WPS to be updated, then?