WPS only hotkey for targets with few buttons?

[Confuseling]

Could a target like the Clip+, which has too few buttons to have a user assignable hotkey in the file browser, have it only available in the WPS? I understand they're separately configured anyway, so it doesn't seem like much of a stretch.

This question motivated by the recent short lived reassignment of 'short down' to open the pitch screen - it caused something of a stir [1] amongst users who use it as a de facto 'turn backlight back on' button. Makes more sense to me to have it user assignable.

[1] http://forums.rockbox.org/index.php?topic=25628.0

[funman]

The hotkey for WPS and filebrowser could be different although it would be confusing IMO.

Long home looks like a good choice but it is quickscreen already, perhaps we could use this key and make quickscreen a hotkey option?

[Confuseling]

The hotkey for WPS and filebrowser could be different although it would be confusing IMO.

I might be completely confused about this (heck, it's happened before :-)), but at the moment there is no hotkey on either screen on these targets is there?

They wouldn't need to be different buttons - it's just allowing one to exist without the other. If you can't have a hotkey on the menu because you need the buttons for the menu itself, I don't see any reason that needs to impact the WPS - just only activate the WPS hotkey. At the moment, 'short down' is a wasted button on the WPS on the Clip for anyone who is happy to use the 'first buttonpress enables backlight only' option as it is intended, and I assume this applies to a fair few players.

Long home looks like a good choice but it is quickscreen already, perhaps we could use this key and make quickscreen a hotkey option?

That also could work, though I'd be surprised if there were many people who would find a hotkey more useful than the quickscreen, as the quicksreen seems a bit like a 'meta-hotkey'. I'm sure they exist though...

EDIT:

The more I think about it, the more it seems that 'back to main menu' on the home button is the weak link. If I ruled the world, short power would be 'back to main menu', left would be 'back', short home would be 'quickscreen', and long home would be 'hotkey'.

I can't think of anything you could actually get 'stuck' in without separate 'left' and 'back' keys, but maybe I'm wrong.

That make more sense to anyone else?