Replay Gain problem with MPC files on a iPod G5.5

[naokoon]

I've noticed that replay gain is not applied to musepack files (SV7) that have only track gain set (and no album gain) when the replay gain type in rockbox's playback settings is set to "album gain". According to the documentation, it should automatically pick track gain whenever there is no album gain tag (this is actually what happens for MP3, OGG, and M4A files). It just doesn't work for musepack files. Replay gain is applied correctly, though, when replay gain type is set to "track gain".

For applying replay gain tags, I used foobar2000 0.9.4.5.

Any ideas?

[soap]

This sounds like a bug, and it sounds like you have done a good job of isolating it.  You should submit this to Flyspray, including all you've said here plus how you know RG isn't being applied.

[naokoon]

You should submit this to Flyspray, including all you've said here plus how you know RG isn't being applied.

Done.

[Lear]

Strange. The same code is used to decide what ReplayGain value to use, regardless of format, so I can't really see how it could work for MP3 but not MPC...

One possibility is that the album gain value is almost, but not quite, zero. Have you tried to edit (or remove) the ReplayGain values for the file in Foobar2000?

And I can't see anything in Flyspray about it...

[naokoon]

http://www.rockbox.org/tracker/task/8251

Seems like the matter was already fixed.

[Lear]

Yes, Thom was too quick for me.