Rockbox makes iAudio x5's disk crash (ATA=-1) - true or false?

[Koziasty]

Hi, some time ago I bought an iAudio x5, and installed rockbox on it. I was using it for about 3 months (Maxwen's build - or something like that, sorry, i can't remeber), when I got an error ATA=-1. Luckily, I was able to get it repaired via the company i bought it from (though they did say rockbox is not supported and my guarantee is voided).
Anyways, i got the player back - but with the original software which is, at least compared to rockbox, crap. I am thinking about installing rockbox again, but am a bit concerned - is there somebody who could for 100% say that it was not rockbox that contributed towards the damage?

I know it says you give no guarantee on how rockbox will work - please do notice im not saying its your fault, I am just asking for your opinions

Regards,
Koziasty

[gnu]

I think it's impossible for rockbox to ruin your HDD. But I don't know for sure.

[Koziasty]

Frankly, I don't know what ruined the hard drive itself - maybe it was the battery that pumped itself up, and created too high a pressure on the drive?
Thanks for your opinion :-)

[gnu]

I don't know too much about HDDs, but as far as I know rockbox simply tells the harddisc to "read from that adress" or "write to that adress".  It's very unlikely that rockbox can ruin your HDD using this commands!

[Koziasty]

As I said - I am not sure if RockBox damaged the harddrive, or caused the battery to swell up (ive seen such a case [battery swelling when Rockbox used] on the internet), or if it has no effect whatsoever.

My question is - is there any possibility RockBox damaged anything within my player that might have caused it to display message ATA=-1.
Thanks!



Thank you. I am willing to give RockBox one more go :] I guess.

[Llorean]

Battery swelling is common without Rockbox installed as well, and happens regularly enough to clearly be simply a manufacturing issue with some batteries.

As for ATA = -1, this can be caused by a variety of issues, one common one is a swolen battery preventing the disk from spinning.